# Kubernetes on OpenStack with Terraform Provision a Kubernetes cluster with [Terraform](https://www.terraform.io) on OpenStack. ## Status This will install a Kubernetes cluster on an OpenStack Cloud. It should work on most modern installs of OpenStack that support the basic services. ### Known compatible public clouds - [Auro](https://auro.io/) - [Betacloud](https://www.betacloud.io/) - [CityCloud](https://www.citycloud.com/) - [DreamHost](https://www.dreamhost.com/cloud/computing/) - [ELASTX](https://elastx.se/) - [EnterCloudSuite](https://www.entercloudsuite.com/) - [FugaCloud](https://fuga.cloud/) - [Open Telekom Cloud](https://cloud.telekom.de/) : requires to set the variable `wait_for_floatingip = "true"` in your cluster.tfvars - [OVH](https://www.ovh.com/) - [Rackspace](https://www.rackspace.com/) - [Ultimum](https://ultimum.io/) - [VexxHost](https://vexxhost.com/) - [Zetta](https://www.zetta.io/) ## Approach The terraform configuration inspects variables found in [variables.tf](variables.tf) to create resources in your OpenStack cluster. There is a [python script](../terraform.py) that reads the generated`.tfstate` file to generate a dynamic inventory that is consumed by the main ansible script to actually install kubernetes and stand up the cluster. ### Networking The configuration includes creating a private subnet with a router to the external net. It will allocate floating IPs from a pool and assign them to the hosts where that makes sense. You have the option of creating bastion hosts inside the private subnet to access the nodes there. Alternatively, a node with a floating IP can be used as a jump host to nodes without. #### Using an existing router It is possible to use an existing router instead of creating one. To use an existing router set the router\_id variable to the uuid of the router you wish to use. For example: ```ShellSession router_id = "00c542e7-6f46-4535-ae95-984c7f0391a3" ``` ### Kubernetes Nodes You can create many different kubernetes topologies by setting the number of different classes of hosts. For each class there are options for allocating floating IP addresses or not. - Master nodes with etcd - Master nodes without etcd - Standalone etcd hosts - Kubernetes worker nodes Note that the Ansible script will report an invalid configuration if you wind up with an even number of etcd instances since that is not a valid configuration. This restriction includes standalone etcd nodes that are deployed in a cluster along with master nodes with etcd replicas. As an example, if you have three master nodes with etcd replicas and three standalone etcd nodes, the script will fail since there are now six total etcd replicas. ### GlusterFS shared file system The Terraform configuration supports provisioning of an optional GlusterFS shared file system based on a separate set of VMs. To enable this, you need to specify: - the number of Gluster hosts (minimum 2) - Size of the non-ephemeral volumes to be attached to store the GlusterFS bricks - Other properties related to provisioning the hosts Even if you are using Flatcar Container Linux by Kinvolk for your cluster, you will still need the GlusterFS VMs to be based on either Debian or RedHat based images. Flatcar Container Linux by Kinvolk cannot serve GlusterFS, but can connect to it through binaries available on hyperkube v1.4.3_coreos.0 or higher. ## Requirements - [Install Terraform](https://www.terraform.io/intro/getting-started/install.html) 0.12 or later - [Install Ansible](http://docs.ansible.com/ansible/latest/intro_installation.html) - you already have a suitable OS image in Glance - you already have a floating IP pool created - you have security groups enabled - you have a pair of keys generated that can be used to secure the new hosts ## Module Architecture The configuration is divided into three modules: - Network - IPs - Compute The main reason for splitting the configuration up in this way is to easily accommodate situations where floating IPs are limited by a quota or if you have any external references to the floating IP (e.g. DNS) that would otherwise have to be updated. You can force your existing IPs by modifying the compute variables in `kubespray.tf` as follows: ```ini k8s_master_fips = ["151.101.129.67"] k8s_node_fips = ["151.101.129.68"] ``` ## Terraform Terraform will be used to provision all of the OpenStack resources with base software as appropriate. ### Configuration #### Inventory files Create an inventory directory for your cluster by copying the existing sample and linking the `hosts` script (used to build the inventory based on Terraform state): ```ShellSession cp -LRp contrib/terraform/openstack/sample-inventory inventory/$CLUSTER cd inventory/$CLUSTER ln -s ../../contrib/terraform/openstack/hosts ln -s ../../contrib ``` This will be the base for subsequent Terraform commands. #### OpenStack access and credentials No provider variables are hardcoded inside `variables.tf` because Terraform supports various authentication methods for OpenStack: the older script and environment method (using `openrc`) as well as a newer declarative method, and different OpenStack environments may support Identity API version 2 or 3. These are examples and may vary depending on your OpenStack cloud provider, for an exhaustive list on how to authenticate on OpenStack with Terraform please read the [OpenStack provider documentation](https://www.terraform.io/docs/providers/openstack/). ##### Declarative method (recommended) The recommended authentication method is to describe credentials in a YAML file `clouds.yaml` that can be stored in: - the current directory - `~/.config/openstack` - `/etc/openstack` `clouds.yaml`: ```yaml clouds: mycloud: auth: auth_url: https://openstack:5000/v3 username: "username" project_name: "projectname" project_id: projectid user_domain_name: "Default" password: "password" region_name: "RegionOne" interface: "public" identity_api_version: 3 ``` If you have multiple clouds defined in your `clouds.yaml` file you can choose the one you want to use with the environment variable `OS_CLOUD`: ```ShellSession export OS_CLOUD=mycloud ``` ##### Openrc method When using classic environment variables, Terraform uses default `OS_*` environment variables. A script suitable for your environment may be available from Horizon under *Project* -> *Compute* -> *Access & Security* -> *API Access*. With identity v2: ```ShellSession source openrc env | grep OS OS_AUTH_URL=https://openstack:5000/v2.0 OS_PROJECT_ID=projectid OS_PROJECT_NAME=projectname OS_USERNAME=username OS_PASSWORD=password OS_REGION_NAME=RegionOne OS_INTERFACE=public OS_IDENTITY_API_VERSION=2 ``` With identity v3: ```ShellSession source openrc env | grep OS OS_AUTH_URL=https://openstack:5000/v3 OS_PROJECT_ID=projectid OS_PROJECT_NAME=username OS_PROJECT_DOMAIN_ID=default OS_USERNAME=username OS_PASSWORD=password OS_REGION_NAME=RegionOne OS_INTERFACE=public OS_IDENTITY_API_VERSION=3 OS_USER_DOMAIN_NAME=Default ``` Terraform does not support a mix of DomainName and DomainID, choose one or the other: - provider.openstack: You must provide exactly one of DomainID or DomainName to authenticate by Username ```ShellSession unset OS_USER_DOMAIN_NAME export OS_USER_DOMAIN_ID=default ``` or ```ShellSession unset OS_PROJECT_DOMAIN_ID set OS_PROJECT_DOMAIN_NAME=Default ``` #### Cluster variables The construction of the cluster is driven by values found in [variables.tf](variables.tf). For your cluster, edit `inventory/$CLUSTER/cluster.tfvars`. |Variable | Description | |---------|-------------| |`cluster_name` | All OpenStack resources will use the Terraform variable`cluster_name` (default`example`) in their name to make it easier to track. For example the first compute resource will be named`example-kubernetes-1`. | |`az_list` | List of Availability Zones available in your OpenStack cluster. | |`network_name` | The name to be given to the internal network that will be generated | |`network_dns_domain` | (Optional) The dns_domain for the internal network that will be generated | |`dns_nameservers`| An array of DNS name server names to be used by hosts in the internal subnet. | |`floatingip_pool` | Name of the pool from which floating IPs will be allocated | |`k8s_master_fips` | A list of floating IPs that you have already pre-allocated; they will be attached to master nodes instead of creating new random floating IPs. | |`external_net` | UUID of the external network that will be routed to | |`flavor_k8s_master`,`flavor_k8s_node`,`flavor_etcd`, `flavor_bastion`,`flavor_gfs_node` | Flavor depends on your openstack installation, you can get available flavor IDs through `openstack flavor list` | |`image`,`image_gfs` | Name of the image to use in provisioning the compute resources. Should already be loaded into glance. | |`ssh_user`,`ssh_user_gfs` | The username to ssh into the image with. This usually depends on the image you have selected | |`public_key_path` | Path on your local workstation to the public key file you wish to use in creating the key pairs | |`number_of_k8s_masters`, `number_of_k8s_masters_no_floating_ip` | Number of nodes that serve as both master and etcd. These can be provisioned with or without floating IP addresses| |`number_of_k8s_masters_no_etcd`, `number_of_k8s_masters_no_floating_ip_no_etcd` | Number of nodes that serve as just master with no etcd. These can be provisioned with or without floating IP addresses | |`number_of_etcd` | Number of pure etcd nodes | |`number_of_k8s_nodes`, `number_of_k8s_nodes_no_floating_ip` | Kubernetes worker nodes. These can be provisioned with or without floating ip addresses. | |`number_of_bastions` | Number of bastion hosts to create. Scripts assume this is really just zero or one | |`number_of_gfs_nodes_no_floating_ip` | Number of gluster servers to provision. | | `gfs_volume_size_in_gb` | Size of the non-ephemeral volumes to be attached to store the GlusterFS bricks | |`supplementary_master_groups` | To add ansible groups to the masters, such as `kube-node` for tainting them as nodes, empty by default. | |`supplementary_node_groups` | To add ansible groups to the nodes, such as `kube-ingress` for running ingress controller pods, empty by default. | |`bastion_allowed_remote_ips` | List of CIDR allowed to initiate a SSH connection, `["0.0.0.0/0"]` by default | |`master_allowed_remote_ips` | List of CIDR blocks allowed to initiate an API connection, `["0.0.0.0/0"]` by default | |`k8s_allowed_remote_ips` | List of CIDR allowed to initiate a SSH connection, empty by default | |`worker_allowed_ports` | List of ports to open on worker nodes, `[{ "protocol" = "tcp", "port_range_min" = 30000, "port_range_max" = 32767, "remote_ip_prefix" = "0.0.0.0/0"}]` by default | |`wait_for_floatingip` | Let Terraform poll the instance until the floating IP has been associated, `false` by default. | |`node_root_volume_size_in_gb` | Size of the root volume for nodes, 0 to use ephemeral storage | |`master_root_volume_size_in_gb` | Size of the root volume for masters, 0 to use ephemeral storage | |`gfs_root_volume_size_in_gb` | Size of the root volume for gluster, 0 to use ephemeral storage | |`etcd_root_volume_size_in_gb` | Size of the root volume for etcd nodes, 0 to use ephemeral storage | |`bastion_root_volume_size_in_gb` | Size of the root volume for bastions, 0 to use ephemeral storage | |`use_server_group` | Create and use openstack nova servergroups, default: false | |`use_access_ip` | If 1, nodes with floating IPs will transmit internal cluster traffic via floating IPs; if 0 private IPs will be used instead. Default value is 1. | |`k8s_nodes` | Map containing worker node definition, see explanation below | ##### k8s_nodes Allows a custom defintion of worker nodes giving the operator full control over individual node flavor and availability zone placement. To enable the use of this mode set the `number_of_k8s_nodes` and `number_of_k8s_nodes_no_floating_ip` variables to 0. Then define your desired worker node configuration using the `k8s_nodes` variable. For example: ```ini k8s_nodes = { "1" = { "az" = "sto1" "flavor" = "83d8b44a-26a0-4f02-a981-079446926445" "floating_ip" = true }, "2" = { "az" = "sto2" "flavor" = "83d8b44a-26a0-4f02-a981-079446926445" "floating_ip" = true }, "3" = { "az" = "sto3" "flavor" = "83d8b44a-26a0-4f02-a981-079446926445" "floating_ip" = true } } ``` Would result in the same configuration as: ```ini number_of_k8s_nodes = 3 flavor_k8s_node = "83d8b44a-26a0-4f02-a981-079446926445" az_list = ["sto1", "sto2", "sto3"] ``` And: ```ini k8s_nodes = { "ing-1" = { "az" = "sto1" "flavor" = "83d8b44a-26a0-4f02-a981-079446926445" "floating_ip" = true }, "ing-2" = { "az" = "sto2" "flavor" = "83d8b44a-26a0-4f02-a981-079446926445" "floating_ip" = true }, "ing-3" = { "az" = "sto3" "flavor" = "83d8b44a-26a0-4f02-a981-079446926445" "floating_ip" = true }, "big-1" = { "az" = "sto1" "flavor" = "3f73fc93-ec61-4808-88df-2580d94c1a9b" "floating_ip" = false }, "big-2" = { "az" = "sto2" "flavor" = "3f73fc93-ec61-4808-88df-2580d94c1a9b" "floating_ip" = false }, "big-3" = { "az" = "sto3" "flavor" = "3f73fc93-ec61-4808-88df-2580d94c1a9b" "floating_ip" = false }, "small-1" = { "az" = "sto1" "flavor" = "7a6a998f-ac7f-4fb8-a534-2175b254f75e" "floating_ip" = false }, "small-2" = { "az" = "sto2" "flavor" = "7a6a998f-ac7f-4fb8-a534-2175b254f75e" "floating_ip" = false }, "small-3" = { "az" = "sto3" "flavor" = "7a6a998f-ac7f-4fb8-a534-2175b254f75e" "floating_ip" = false } } ``` Would result in three nodes in each availability zone each with their own separate naming, flavor and floating ip configuration. The "schema": ```ini k8s_nodes = { "key | node name suffix, must be unique" = { "az" = string "flavor" = string "floating_ip" = bool }, } ``` All values are required. #### Terraform state files In the cluster's inventory folder, the following files might be created (either by Terraform or manually), to prevent you from pushing them accidentally they are in a `.gitignore` file in the `terraform/openstack` directory : - `.terraform` - `.tfvars` - `.tfstate` - `.tfstate.backup` You can still add them manually if you want to. ### Initialization Before Terraform can operate on your cluster you need to install the required plugins. This is accomplished as follows: ```ShellSession cd inventory/$CLUSTER terraform init ../../contrib/terraform/openstack ``` This should finish fairly quickly telling you Terraform has successfully initialized and loaded necessary modules. ### Provisioning cluster You can apply the Terraform configuration to your cluster with the following command issued from your cluster's inventory directory (`inventory/$CLUSTER`): ```ShellSession terraform apply -var-file=cluster.tfvars ../../contrib/terraform/openstack ``` if you chose to create a bastion host, this script will create `contrib/terraform/openstack/k8s-cluster.yml` with an ssh command for Ansible to be able to access your machines tunneling through the bastion's IP address. If you want to manually handle the ssh tunneling to these machines, please delete or move that file. If you want to use this, just leave it there, as ansible will pick it up automatically. ### Destroying cluster You can destroy your new cluster with the following command issued from the cluster's inventory directory: ```ShellSession terraform destroy -var-file=cluster.tfvars ../../contrib/terraform/openstack ``` If you've started the Ansible run, it may also be a good idea to do some manual cleanup: - remove SSH keys from the destroyed cluster from your `~/.ssh/known_hosts` file - clean up any temporary cache files: `rm /tmp/$CLUSTER-*` ### Debugging You can enable debugging output from Terraform by setting `OS_DEBUG` to 1 and`TF_LOG` to`DEBUG` before running the Terraform command. ### Terraform output Terraform can output values that are useful for configure Neutron/Octavia LBaaS or Cinder persistent volume provisioning as part of your Kubernetes deployment: - `private_subnet_id`: the subnet where your instances are running is used for `openstack_lbaas_subnet_id` - `floating_network_id`: the network_id where the floating IP are provisioned is used for `openstack_lbaas_floating_network_id` ## Ansible ### Node access #### SSH Ensure your local ssh-agent is running and your ssh key has been added. This step is required by the terraform provisioner: ```ShellSession eval $(ssh-agent -s) ssh-add ~/.ssh/id_rsa ``` If you have deployed and destroyed a previous iteration of your cluster, you will need to clear out any stale keys from your SSH "known hosts" file ( `~/.ssh/known_hosts`). #### Metadata variables The [python script](../terraform.py) that reads the generated`.tfstate` file to generate a dynamic inventory recognizes some variables within a "metadata" block, defined in a "resource" block (example): ```ini resource "openstack_compute_instance_v2" "example" { ... metadata { ssh_user = "ubuntu" prefer_ipv6 = true python_bin = "/usr/bin/python3" } ... } ``` As the example shows, these let you define the SSH username for Ansible, a Python binary which is needed by Ansible if `/usr/bin/python` doesn't exist, and whether the IPv6 address of the instance should be preferred over IPv4. #### Bastion host Bastion access will be determined by: - Your choice on the amount of bastion hosts (set by `number_of_bastions` terraform variable). - The existence of nodes/masters with floating IPs (set by `number_of_k8s_masters`, `number_of_k8s_nodes`, `number_of_k8s_masters_no_etcd` terraform variables). If you have a bastion host, your ssh traffic will be directly routed through it. This is regardless of whether you have masters/nodes with a floating IP assigned. If you don't have a bastion host, but at least one of your masters/nodes have a floating IP, then ssh traffic will be tunneled by one of these machines. So, either a bastion host, or at least master/node with a floating IP are required. #### Test access Make sure you can connect to the hosts. Note that Flatcar Container Linux by Kinvolk will have a state `FAILED` due to Python not being present. This is okay, because Python will be installed during bootstrapping, so long as the hosts are not `UNREACHABLE`. ```ShellSession $ ansible -i inventory/$CLUSTER/hosts -m ping all example-k8s_node-1 | SUCCESS => { "changed": false, "ping": "pong" } example-etcd-1 | SUCCESS => { "changed": false, "ping": "pong" } example-k8s-master-1 | SUCCESS => { "changed": false, "ping": "pong" } ``` If it fails try to connect manually via SSH. It could be something as simple as a stale host key. ### Configure cluster variables Edit `inventory/$CLUSTER/group_vars/all/all.yml`: - **bin_dir**: ```yml # Directory where the binaries will be installed # Default: # bin_dir: /usr/local/bin # For Flatcar Container Linux by Kinvolk: bin_dir: /opt/bin ``` - and **cloud_provider**: ```yml cloud_provider: openstack ``` Edit `inventory/$CLUSTER/group_vars/k8s-cluster/k8s-cluster.yml`: - Set variable **kube_network_plugin** to your desired networking plugin. - **flannel** works out-of-the-box - **calico** requires [configuring OpenStack Neutron ports](/docs/openstack.md) to allow service and pod subnets ```yml # Choose network plugin (calico, weave or flannel) # Can also be set to 'cloud', which lets the cloud provider setup appropriate routing kube_network_plugin: flannel ``` - Set variable **resolvconf_mode** ```yml # Can be docker_dns, host_resolvconf or none # Default: # resolvconf_mode: docker_dns # For Flatcar Container Linux by Kinvolk: resolvconf_mode: host_resolvconf ``` - Set max amount of attached cinder volume per host (default 256) ```yml node_volume_attach_limit: 26 ``` ### Deploy Kubernetes ```ShellSession ansible-playbook --become -i inventory/$CLUSTER/hosts cluster.yml ``` This will take some time as there are many tasks to run. ## Kubernetes ### Set up kubectl 1. [Install kubectl](https://kubernetes.io/docs/tasks/tools/install-kubectl/) on your workstation 2. Add a route to the internal IP of a master node (if needed): ```ShellSession sudo route add [master-internal-ip] gw [router-ip] ``` or ```ShellSession sudo route add -net [internal-subnet]/24 gw [router-ip] ``` 1. List Kubernetes certificates & keys: ```ShellSession ssh [os-user]@[master-ip] sudo ls /etc/kubernetes/ssl/ ``` 1. Get `admin`'s certificates and keys: ```ShellSession ssh [os-user]@[master-ip] sudo cat /etc/kubernetes/ssl/admin-kube-master-1-key.pem > admin-key.pem ssh [os-user]@[master-ip] sudo cat /etc/kubernetes/ssl/admin-kube-master-1.pem > admin.pem ssh [os-user]@[master-ip] sudo cat /etc/kubernetes/ssl/ca.pem > ca.pem ``` 1. Configure kubectl: ```ShellSession $ kubectl config set-cluster default-cluster --server=https://[master-internal-ip]:6443 \ --certificate-authority=ca.pem $ kubectl config set-credentials default-admin \ --certificate-authority=ca.pem \ --client-key=admin-key.pem \ --client-certificate=admin.pem $ kubectl config set-context default-system --cluster=default-cluster --user=default-admin $ kubectl config use-context default-system ``` 1. Check it: ```ShellSession kubectl version ``` ## GlusterFS GlusterFS is not deployed by the standard `cluster.yml` playbook, see the [GlusterFS playbook documentation](../../network-storage/glusterfs/README.md) for instructions. Basically you will install Gluster as ```ShellSession ansible-playbook --become -i inventory/$CLUSTER/hosts ./contrib/network-storage/glusterfs/glusterfs.yml ``` ## What's next Try out your new Kubernetes cluster with the [Hello Kubernetes service](https://kubernetes.io/docs/tasks/access-application-cluster/service-access-application-cluster/). ## Appendix ### Migration from `number_of_k8s_nodes*` to `k8s_nodes` If you currently have a cluster defined using the `number_of_k8s_nodes*` variables and wish to migrate to the `k8s_nodes` style you can do it like so: ```ShellSession $ terraform state list module.compute.data.openstack_images_image_v2.gfs_image module.compute.data.openstack_images_image_v2.vm_image module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_master[0] module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[0] module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[1] module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[2] module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_master[0] module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[0] module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[1] module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[2] module.compute.openstack_compute_keypair_v2.k8s module.compute.openstack_compute_servergroup_v2.k8s_etcd[0] module.compute.openstack_compute_servergroup_v2.k8s_master[0] module.compute.openstack_compute_servergroup_v2.k8s_node[0] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.bastion[0] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.egress[0] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.k8s module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.k8s_allowed_remote_ips[0] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.k8s_allowed_remote_ips[1] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.k8s_allowed_remote_ips[2] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.k8s_master[0] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.worker[0] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.worker[1] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.worker[2] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.worker[3] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_rule_v2.worker[4] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_v2.bastion[0] module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_v2.k8s module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_v2.k8s_master module.compute.openstack_networking_secgroup_v2.worker module.ips.null_resource.dummy_dependency module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_master[0] module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[0] module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[1] module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[2] module.network.openstack_networking_network_v2.k8s[0] module.network.openstack_networking_router_interface_v2.k8s[0] module.network.openstack_networking_router_v2.k8s[0] module.network.openstack_networking_subnet_v2.k8s[0] $ terraform state mv 'module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[0]' 'module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_nodes["1"]' Move "module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[0]" to "module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_nodes[\"1\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[1]' 'module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_nodes["2"]' Move "module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[1]" to "module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_nodes[\"2\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[2]' 'module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_nodes["3"]' Move "module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_node[2]" to "module.compute.openstack_compute_floatingip_associate_v2.k8s_nodes[\"3\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[0]' 'module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node["1"]' Move "module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[0]" to "module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[\"1\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[1]' 'module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node["2"]' Move "module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[1]" to "module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[\"2\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[2]' 'module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node["3"]' Move "module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[2]" to "module.compute.openstack_compute_instance_v2.k8s_node[\"3\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[0]' 'module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node["1"]' Move "module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[0]" to "module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[\"1\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[1]' 'module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node["2"]' Move "module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[1]" to "module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[\"2\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). $ terraform state mv 'module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[2]' 'module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node["3"]' Move "module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[2]" to "module.ips.openstack_networking_floatingip_v2.k8s_node[\"3\"]" Successfully moved 1 object(s). ``` Of course for nodes without floating ips those steps can be omitted.